Impeachment fears: Cachalia urges ANC to safeguard Ramaphosa
Acting Police Minister Firoz Cachalia’s impartiality has come under scrutiny following his remarks that removing President Cyril Ramaphosa from office could trigger national instability.
Image: Supplied
Acting Police Minister Firoz Cachalia has sparked controversy by urging the ANC and other parties in the Government of National Unity (GNU) to protect President Cyril Ramaphosa from possible impeachment.
Cachalia, who made these remarks during an interview with eNCA, stated that impeaching Ramaphosa will destabilise the country, adding that the ANC and its partners in the GNU must protect him.
While the ANC announced its support for Ramaphosa, the DA stated its commitment to the GNU saying it will not trade accountability for political power.
Ramaphosa faces a newly established parliamentary impeachment committee investigating his conduct in the Phala Phala farm scandal.
This major development follows the Constitutional Court ruling, which declared Parliament’s previous 2022 block of the inquiry unlawful.
The court ruled that Parliament acted unconstitutionally by dismissing a Section 89 Independent Panel report, which found ‘prima facie’ evidence of serious misconduct regarding $580 000 in cash hidden in a sofa on Ramaphosa's farm.
Governance expert and political analyst Sandile Swana said there is political bias coming from Cachalia’s remarks, as he had been close to Ramaphosa during their anti-apartheid activism within the United Democratic Front (UDF) in the 1980s.
Swana added that Cachalia’s statement could also imply that Ramaphosa should never be investigated and punished, regardless of what he has done.
He called on Cachalia to identify the instigators of any possible form of instability and report this to the intelligence services and arrest them.
“It is Cachalia’s job to make sure that there is no chaos if Ramaphosa is removed. He should protect the internal stability of the country,” Swana said.
Cachalia's spokesperson, Kamo Mogotsi said the Minister could not respond to queries on his remarks as he was preparing to table his 2026/27 Budget on Tuesday.
Mogotsi added that the Minister was willing to discuss the rationale behind his comments.
National Assembly Speaker Thoko Didiza last week established a 31-member Section 89 Impeachment Committee to investigate and determine whether there is sufficient evidence to impeach Ramaphosa.
Political parties have until May 22 to submit their finalised member nominations.
The 31 seats are allocated among 16 political parties as follows: ANC (9 seats), DA (5), MK Party (3), EFF (2), and one seat each for the IFP, PA, FF Plus, ActionSA, ACDP, UDM, RISE Mzansi, BOSA, ATM, Al Jama-ah, NCC, and UAT.
Political analyst Kim Heller said constitutional accountability cannot ever be "destabilising", adding that political accountability must always trump the shielding of political elites.
“These remarks disrespect the democratic processes and add to political disillusionment among South Africans,” she said.
Professor Sipho Seepe said that this set a dangerous precedent that Ramaphosa is above the law, adding that the country has seen law enforcement failing to do their job to hold him accountable.
“The NPA has been unwilling to charge in the face of prima facie evidence pointing to the fact that he has a case to answer,” he said.