Winde faces backlash from Cape Flats communities over SANDF deployment and violence

Cape Flats communities and political parties are growing tired of the ongoing discussions about military deployment without any clear action to tackle the violence in the area.  

This frustration comes after Premier Alan Winde recently presented a report on gang infiltration and responded to questions from the Patriotic Alliance’s Donna Stephens about the potential deployment of the South African National Defence Force (SANDF) to the Cape Flats.

“I think that's a very interesting question, and maybe it is something that you should put to us to discuss at the Safety Council. (My) immediate gut answer to that is, I don't think so.

"I requested this once before. I've been in government for quite a long time, and in 2019, just as I became the premier. We were having shootings across the Cape Flats just before an election again, and it feels a bit like deja vu,” Winde said.

"And I said, 'We need the military'. And that wasn't the first time. That was, I think, the second or third time that the military in the last 30 years has been brought in to deal with the gang violence.

"I think the real problem is that even when that happens, the military is trained for something else. 

"I mean, the military system is totally underfunded and totally inefficient. And so you're gonna add another inefficiency to another inefficiency.. (in) my gut, I don't think it is actually going to make a difference."

Fight Against Crime Spokesperson Jay Jay Idel said he finds it “quite something” that the premier leans on his experience in government, “when, during that same time, more than 400 people were killed this year in just the top 30 stations in the very province he leads”.

“Calling for the SANDF isn’t rocket science. People are being murdered every weekend in numbers...it's so predictable it feels scheduled. 

“At this point, it sounds like the premier is effectively admitting he doesn’t have an answer for gang violence on the Cape Flats.”

Elsies River CPF chairperson Marius Fourie said: “Deployment of the military on the Cape Flats is a very serious move, and all role players will need to be on board for this. The military does not have the training to be a police force; however, they do have the skills to be a peacekeeper. They can be deployed at many hotspots and even smash and grabbing spots. They are there and should be utilised. 

“These gangsters are not using hands, but military grade weapons to attack our community. 

“On a recent WhatsApp poll in Elsies River, the community overwhelmingly voted to deploy the military. Whilst it is a very controversial question, it is what the community is asking for,” Fourie said.

Mitchells Plain Community Policing Forum (CPF) Public Relations Officer, Linda Jones, said accused Winde of not having a 'clear answer to our problem and no political will to eradicate crime in the Western Cape'.

“They must just admit they have no real solution to the problem. They are unable to solve it. Why? Because nothing for us without us.

“We are fed up with being seen as the easy targets. Our children are killed, and we can't enjoy freedom. We are worse off than the inmates in prisons,” Jones said.

GOOD Secretary-General Brett Herron said, given the war zone that the people on the Cape Flats are living in, it is unsurprising that there is a call for the presence of the military again.

“It is important to understand the call for the symbol of a force of power because communities are living with fear and desperation. But the army is not trained in crime prevention. They are trained for military combat,” Herron said.

Get your news on the go, click here to join the Cape Argus News WhatsApp channel.

Cape Argus