Convicted rapist and murderer sentenced to life for the killing of 6-year-old Amantle Samane

The sentencing of 25-year-old Phethe Simiao to two life terms by the Gauteng South High Court in Johannesburg has been met with relief by the Samane family and the community of Orlando East, Soweto.

Simiao was found guilty of the kidnapping, rape, and murder of 6-year-old Amantle Samane in October 2024, a crime that has deeply affected the local community.

Speaking after the judgment on Monday, Amantle's mother, Ntombizodwa Samane, welcomed the sentence, saying her child will now rest in peace knowing that her rapist has finally been convicted.

"This well-received sentence will deter other men from killing and raping our children. Maybe then they will stop," she said.

Samane said the family is still reeling from the death of their child.

"We are still mourning our child and are yet to find closure, even though he has been found guilty. He is yet to tell us what drove him to rape and kill our child," she said.

The sentencing was handed down by Judge William Karam, who said the court was satisfied with the evidence following Simiao's arrest over 10 months ago.

"On August 15, the accused pleaded guilty to all charges as charged. 

"The viciousness of Simiao’s actions rules out any immaturity, as he was 24 years old at the time the crimes were committed," Judge Karam said.

Simiao had pleaded for leniency, expressing regret and apologising during his plea, with Judge Karam finding no evidence of genuine remorse, highlighting that Simiao did not testify in court.

"His failure to testify leaves many questions, like how long the minor was kept hostage before he raped her, how long after the rape did he murder her, and how long did the rape endure?" added Judge Karam.

Over the past 10 months, GBV organisations and community members have been following the matter with keen interest, with some residents picketing outside the court.

Gender-based violence activist, Gina Mthina, also welcomed the judgment, saying that as members of the community, they feel vindicated by the sentence.

"We welcome and appreciate the sentence that was given by the judge today. Our prayers have been answered, and we hope others will be deterred by this sentence," she said.

Speaking on behalf of the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA), spokesperson Phindi Mjonondwane welcomed the sentence, saying: " We are happy with the sentence as the NPA, and we continue with our resilience in the fight against violent crimes, especially those against vulnerable groups."

Get your news on the go, click here to join the Cape Argus News WhatsApp channel.

Cape Argus